Reading and inquiry pedagogy

From Retrieval to Reasoning

Year 6 Reading · Social Sciences · Critical thinking

A Year 6 questioning sequence that uses reading as the knowledge base for explanation, evidence-informed reasoning, and transfer.

Four question levels, from retrieval to transfer.

Lesson sequence · teaching reflection

Final lecturer report: critical thinking through questioning and debate

How can I move learners from locating information in a text to explaining relationships, using evidence, and transferring an idea to a new context?

The sequence used texts about Athens and Sparta, retrieval questions, sequenced why-questions, prompts for textual support, and a familiar hypothetical context for persuasive argument.

I used retrieval as the entry point, then selected the next prompt from learner responses: extend the reasoning, request textual support, revisit background knowledge, or invite revision.

Each question asks for more than the last.

Retrieval established shared knowledge. Each later question asked learners to do more with it.

  1. 01

    Retrieve

    What did Athenians study?

    Establish accurate shared knowledge from the text.

  2. 02

    Explain

    Why did rhetoric matter in a democracy?

    Connect persuasion, citizenship, and decision-making.

  3. 03

    Justify

    What makes you think that?

    Support the explanation with information from the reading.

  4. 04

    Transfer

    Persuade the class in a familiar situation.

    Apply the principle of persuasion in a new context.

Each response decided the next prompt

  • Extend the reasoning
  • Request textual support
  • Revisit background knowledge
  • Invite revision

Evidence boundary The questions summarise the planned sequence; they do not quote learners.

Final lecturer report · 2026

Learners had to justify their ideas.

My lecturer’s final report noted that I develop learners’ critical thinking through higher-order questioning and strategies such as debate, which require learners to justify their ideas.

Evidence boundary Confirms the teaching approach, not individual learner outcomes.

Initial responses frequently stopped at factual retrieval. Follow-up prompts requiring ‘why?’ and ‘what makes you think that?’ produced longer explanations and greater use of information from the text. No individual result or percentage is published.

I use retrieval as the entry point to comprehension, not as the endpoint of thinking. My next step is to keep making the move from answer to explanation explicit.
Standard 2Know the content and how to teach itStandard 3Know the learner and the learning processStandard 4Plan for and implement effective teaching and learning