Reading assessment in practice

From Reading Evidence to the Next Teaching Move

Years 3–4 Reading · Vocabulary · Comprehension · Assessment

A Years 3–4 case showing how explicit vocabulary and comprehension teaching, Running Records, and daily small-group evidence led to different next steps for different readers.

Three groups, three different next moves chosen from daily evaluation.

Lesson evaluations · Running Records · one observed lesson

Associate Teacher observed one reading lesson, not the three-group next steps

How can I distinguish whether a learner needs support with decoding, fluency, comprehension, summarising, or participation—and then change the next lesson accordingly?

An observed vocabulary and Question–Answer Relationships lesson, one-to-one Running Records, oral reading and retell, written responses, and daily small-group evaluations.

I did not treat the group as a single reading profile. I separated decoding accuracy, fluency, comprehension, summary, and participation, then selected the next scaffold or prompt from the need that was actually visible.

Three groups. Three different next moves.

My daily evaluations located a different need in each group, so each group got a different next lesson.

Reading needs located by daily evaluation, by group
GroupComprehensionRetell and summaryFluencyParticipation
News-reading groupEvidence showed this was in placeNext teaching focusNot the focus of this evaluationNot the focus of this evaluation
Second reading groupEvidence showed this was in placeNext teaching focusNext teaching focusNot the focus of this evaluation
Follow-up lesson groupEvidence showed this was in placeNot the focus of this evaluationNot the focus of this evaluationNext teaching focus
  1. News-reading group

    EvidenceUnderstood most of the article, but did not know how to begin the news review.

    Next moveCo-construct the news review again with more explicit scaffolding.

  2. Second reading group

    EvidenceRetold the basic idea, but some retells were short and fluency needed work.

    Next moveAdd more reading aloud to hear and support sentence-level meaning.

  3. Follow-up lesson group

    EvidenceRecalled the previous day’s plot, main topic, and problem; the participation routine needed changing.

    Next moveChange how I led the group so learners took an active role.

Evidence boundary From my completed lesson evaluations; it shows how I chose the next step, not reading levels or measured progress.

Associate Teacher observation · 2026

The reading lesson was well organised and planned.

An Associate Teacher observed the vocabulary and Question–Answer Relationships lesson and noted that learners were engaged and asked useful questions.

Evidence boundary Feedback from one lesson; not reading attainment or sustained impact.

After I changed how I led the follow-up lesson, a learner who had been reluctant to contribute led some of the reading and responding. This is one observed participation change, not a claim of sustained progress.

Assessment is useful when it changes the next lesson. My next step is to link phonics and spelling evidence more systematically with oral reading and comprehension.
Standard 2Know the content and how to teach itStandard 3Know the learner and the learning processStandard 4Plan for and implement effective teaching and learningStandard 6Assess, provide feedback, and report on learning